What To Expect At Mediation For Personal Injury: A Solicitor’s Guide

8 min read
Oct 13, 2026, 10:00:00 AM

For solicitors handling personal injury claims, effective mediation begins well before the parties enter the mediation room.

Preparation involves more than assembling medical evidence and calculating settlement parameters. Legal teams need to ensure that the right evidence is available, the client understands the process, relevant decision-makers can participate and the mediator understands the issues that are genuinely preventing resolution.

On the day itself, mediation provides a structured but flexible environment in which the parties can test assumptions, assess litigation risk and explore whether an acceptable settlement can be reached.

Importantly, the mediator does not decide the case. The parties retain control over whether they settle and the terms upon which any agreement is reached.

Understanding what to expect before, during and after a personal injury mediation allows solicitors and counsel to prepare strategically and help clients participate effectively in the process.

1. Before The Mediation: Is The Claim Ready?

The first question is not simply whether mediation could assist, but whether the claim is sufficiently developed for meaningful negotiations to take place.

In a personal injury claim, legal teams will usually want sufficient information to assess the principal areas of risk and potential value.

Depending on the case, this may include:

  • pleadings and relevant liability evidence;
  • medical and expert reports;
  • a schedule of loss;
  • evidence relating to earnings and future loss;
  • care, case management or accommodation evidence;
  • relevant surveillance or other evidential material; and
  • previous Part 36 or settlement offers, where appropriate.

Not every evidential issue needs to have been exhausted before mediation can take place. A trial bundle is not a precondition for settlement.

The relevant question is whether the parties have enough information to make informed decisions about litigation risk and settlement.

Timing is therefore important. A mediation held too early may be hindered by significant evidential gaps. One held too late may take place only after substantial avoidable litigation costs have already been incurred.

2. Preparing The Client For Mediation

Client preparation is particularly important in personal injury mediation. For many claimants, mediation will be unfamiliar. They may expect something resembling a court hearing or assume they will be required to speak directly to the defendant, insurer or opposing legal team.

Solicitors should explain in advance:

  • the mediator's role;
  • who is expected to attend;
  • the confidential and generally without prejudice nature of the process;
  • how private and any joint discussions may operate;
  • that the mediator will not determine the claim;
  • that settlement cannot be imposed upon them;
  • how offers and counter-offers may be communicated;
  • what authority may be required to settle; and
  • what happens if no agreement is reached.

The legal team should also prepare and agree with their client a negotiation strategy for the day of the mediation. This should be based on the evidence available and also be flexible enough to enable the negotiations to be approached with an open mind. Such flexibility means that the strategy may be tailored on the day, depending on what is learned during the mediation.

The client's role should also be considered carefully. Some claimants may want an opportunity to explain the personal impact of the injury. Others may prefer their legal representatives to conduct most of the discussions.

There is no requirement for every mediation to follow the same format. The process can be adapted to the circumstances of the individual claim and the needs of those participating.

3. Position Statements And The Mediation Bundle

The mediator will usually require relevant information about the dispute before the mediation. This may include a focused bundle of key documents together with case summaries or position statements from the parties.

An effective case summary or position statement should help the mediator understand what is preventing settlement, rather than simply reproduce pleadings or advocacy already familiar to the opposing legal team.

Depending on the case, it may address:

  1. The Core Issues: The principal areas of disagreement concerning liability, causation or quantum.
  2. The Evidence: The evidence that materially affects the parties' respective assessments of those issues.
  3. The Procedural Position: Relevant forthcoming hearings, trial dates or other significant milestones.
  4. Previous Negotiations: Where appropriate, sufficient context about the negotiating history to help the mediator understand why discussions have stalled.
  5. Practical Obstacles: Any non-legal considerations or dynamics that may be relevant to achieving resolution.
  6. The Purpose Of The Mediation: The issues the party considers capable of being explored or resolved during the process.

The most useful position statements are generally focused, use constructive language and are written with the mediation itself in mind. Although the position statement is addressed to the mediator it can be a useful medium to flag to the other party(ies) how you are approaching the mediation.

4. Preliminary Contact With The Mediator

Depending on the mediator and the nature of the case, there may be preliminary contact with the parties or their legal representatives before the mediation.

This can help the mediator understand the background to the dispute, identify practical or interpersonal considerations and determine how the mediation might best be structured.

For personal injury cases, preliminary discussions may cover matters such as:

  • particularly sensitive client circumstances;
  • significant areas of disagreement between experts;
  • previous unsuccessful negotiations, procedural hearings or JSMs;
  • multi-party or indemnity issues;
  • who will attend and who has settlement authority;
  • whether joint discussions are likely to be productive; and
  • any practical arrangements required for the claimant or other participants.

This stage can be particularly useful where the written papers do not fully explain the dynamics that have prevented the claim from settling.

5. What Happens On The Day Of Mediation?

There is no single mandatory format for a personal injury mediation. The mediator will usually structure the process around the circumstances of the claim and the parties involved.

A mediation may include:

Initial Discussions

The mediator may begin by meeting the parties separately, jointly or through a combination of both approaches. The purpose is usually to establish how the process will operate, confirm the mediator's role and begin identifying the principal obstacles to resolution.

Private Sessions

Much of the mediation may take place through confidential private meetings between the mediator and each party.

These discussions provide an opportunity to explore the case in greater depth, including:

  • strengths and weaknesses in the evidence;
  • litigation and trial risk;
  • differences in the parties' valuation;
  • settlement priorities;
  • practical concerns; and
  • potential areas of movement.

Information disclosed privately to the mediator is not communicated to the other party without permission.

Joint Discussions

Joint meetings may also be used where the mediator and parties consider them productive. These might involve the clients, legal representatives, experts or particular combinations of attendees depending upon the issue being discussed.

A joint session is a tool rather than a requirement. It is used where it is likely to advance the process.

Negotiation

As discussions develop, the mediator may move between the parties, helping them communicate proposals, understand the reasoning behind their respective positions and explore whether the gap can be narrowed.

The mediator does not simply carry offers from one room to another. An effective mediator helps the parties examine the assumptions and risks underlying those offers and identify whether alternative approaches to resolution are available.

6. What Does The Solicitor Do During Mediation?

The solicitor's role remains central throughout the process. Mediation does not transfer responsibility for the case to the mediator.

Solicitors continue to:

  • advise their client on the legal and evidential position;
  • assess offers and counter-offers;
  • explain litigation and costs risks;
  • work with counsel (where instructed);
  • ensure that the client understands proposed settlement terms;
  • protect the client's interests throughout negotiations; and
  • record any settlement appropriately.

The mediator facilitates the process but does not replace the client's legal advisers.

This distinction is particularly important where a claimant is being asked to make significant decisions concerning a high-value or life-changing claim.

7. Does The Client Have To Settle?

No. The mediator cannot impose a settlement, determine liability or require either party to accept a proposal. The decision whether to settle remains with the parties. This is one of the principal distinctions between mediation and adjudicative processes such as trial or arbitration. If the claimant or defendant concludes that the terms available are not acceptable, they can decline them and continue with the litigation.

The value of mediation is therefore not that it removes decision-making from the parties, but that it provides a structured environment in which those decisions can be made with a clearer understanding of the available options and litigation risks.

8. What Happens If Settlement Is Reached?

Where the parties reach agreement, the terms should be recorded carefully before the mediation concludes. The appropriate documentation will depend on the nature and procedural stage of the claim and may include a settlement agreement, a draft Tomlin Order or consent order, or other appropriate documentation.

Legal representatives should ensure that all material terms have been addressed. Depending on the claim, this may include:

  • the settlement amount (and whether inclusive or exclusive of any interim payment(s));
  • costs arrangements;
  • payment arrangements;
  • any relevant benefits or recoupment considerations (CRU);
  • confidentiality provisions where appropriate;
  • the treatment of any outstanding issues; and
  • any procedural steps required to conclude the proceedings.

In cases involving protected parties, children or other circumstances requiring court approval, additional procedural steps may be necessary before the settlement becomes effective.

9. What Happens If The Case Does Not Settle?

A mediation does not always result in settlement on the day. In a significant proportion of cases that do not settle on the day the parties reach final agreement shortly afterwards.

If no agreement is reached, the parties ordinarily remain free to continue with the litigation. However, the mediation may have clarified matters that influence subsequent negotiations.

For example, the process may have:

  • identified the principal obstacle to settlement;
  • narrowed particular areas of disagreement;
  • revealed that further evidence is required;
  • clarified the parties' respective assessments of risk; or
  • established a basis for further negotiations.

The mediator may also remain involved after the mediation where the parties agree that further assistance would be useful.

It is important not to assume that every unsuccessful mediation will necessarily produce these benefits. The value of the process will depend on the dispute, the parties' engagement and the timing of the mediation.

10. How Should Solicitors Prepare For A Productive PI Mediation?

Before the mediation, legal teams should consider a practical checklist:

  • Is sufficient evidence available for informed negotiations?
  • Are the schedule and counter-schedule sufficiently developed?
  • Have the key liability, causation and quantum issues been identified?
  • Have we prepared a negotiation strategy for the day of the mediation and agreed it with the client?
  • Does the mediator have the documents genuinely required to understand those issues?
  • Has the client been properly prepared for the process?
  • Are the relevant decision-makers attending or readily available?
  • Is appropriate settlement authority available?
  • Have litigation and costs risks been assessed?
  • Are there upcoming procedural milestones that affect negotiations?
  • Have the legal representatives considered how settlement will be documented if agreement is reached?

Preparation should focus not simply on presenting the strongest possible case, but on understanding what is preventing settlement and what would be required to overcome that obstacle.

11. Supporting Legal Teams: Trust ADR And ADR Champions

Trust ADR works alongside claimant and defendant solicitors, counsel and other legal professionals to provide access to experienced independent neutrals for personal injury, clinical negligence and civil disputes.

Where mediation is being considered, Trust ADR can assist with mediator selection, process planning and the practical arrangements required for the individual case.

For firms seeking to develop a more systematic approach to ADR, Trust ADR also offers the ADR Champions programme. It is designed to help firms build internal awareness and establish a clearer route for practitioners preparing for mediation or considering ADR across their caseloads.

Participating firms can benefit from:

  • A Designated ADR Contact: A nominated practitioner within the firm who can act as an internal point of contact and liaise with Trust ADR.
  • Practical Process Guidance: Support when considering mediation suitability, timing, mediator expertise and preparation.
  • Knowledge Sharing: Relevant updates concerning ADR practice, case law, procedural developments and evolving court expectations.
  • Training And Practical Support: Resources designed to help practitioners and their teams prepare effectively for mediation and discuss the process confidently with clients.

The objective is to help legal teams approach mediation strategically and arrive properly prepared to make productive use of the process.

Preparing For A Personal Injury Mediation?

If you have an active personal injury or clinical negligence claim approaching mediation, or you are considering whether a structured neutral process could help move negotiations forward, Trust ADR can discuss the available options.

We can consider the issues in dispute, the appropriate timing and format, the expertise required from the mediator and practical arrangements for the session.

Contact Trust ADR to discuss mediator availability and the appropriate setup for an upcoming personal injury or clinical negligence mediation.

Image Source: Envato

Get Email Notifications