What Did Churchill Change?
The Court of Appeal's decision in Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416 represented an important development in the law concerning compulsory ADR.
The Court of Appeal confirmed that a court can lawfully stay proceedings for, or order parties to engage in, a non-court-based dispute resolution process.
Any such order must not impair the very essence of the claimant's right to a judicial hearing and must be proportionate to the legitimate aim of settling the dispute fairly, quickly and at reasonable cost.
The judgment moved the position beyond the earlier assumption that unwilling parties could not be compelled to participate in ADR.
Importantly, however, Churchill concerned non-court-based dispute resolution generally. The appropriate process will depend upon the circumstances of the individual case.
For PI practitioners, the practical implication is that mediation should no longer be regarded solely as an optional process considered after conventional negotiations have failed. ADR will now form part of active judicial case management.
What Do The Civil Procedure Rules Say About ADR?
The procedural position developed further on 1 October 2024 when amendments to the Civil Procedure Rules came into force through the Civil Procedure (Amendment No. 3) Rules 2024.
Those amendments expressly incorporated ADR into important parts of the CPR framework.
In particular:
- The Overriding Objective (CPR 1.1): The overriding objective expressly includes promoting or using alternative dispute resolution.
- The Court's Duty To Manage Cases (CPR 1.4): Active case management includes encouraging the parties to use, and facilitating the use of, ADR where appropriate.
- Case Management Powers (CPR 3.1): The court's general case management powers expressly include ordering the parties to engage in ADR.(See also CPR Parts 28 and 29, regarding case management.)
- Costs (CPR 44.2): Conduct relating to ADR can be relevant when the court exercises its discretion as to costs, including a failure to comply with an order for ADR or an unreasonable failure to engage in ADR.
The combined effect is that ADR now forms an express part of the procedural framework within which civil claims are managed.
Can A Court Specifically Order Mediation?
A court has the power to order parties to engage in ADR. Whether mediation is the appropriate form of ADR will depend on the nature of the dispute and the circumstances of the case.
This distinction is important.
ADR encompasses a range of processes, and mediation will not necessarily be the appropriate mechanism in every claim. In some cases, another process may be more suitable.
Where mediation is considered appropriate, however, the fact that participation has been ordered does not mean that the parties are required to compromise their legal positions or reach a settlement.
The distinction is between participating in a process and being compelled to agree an outcome.
During mediation:
- the parties retain responsibility for their litigation strategy;
- solicitors and counsel continue to advise their clients;
- neither party is required to accept a settlement proposal;
- the mediator cannot impose an outcome; and
- if no agreement is reached, the litigation can continue.
For personal injury practitioners, this preserves an important element of client autonomy even where participation in an ADR process arises through case management directions.
What Does Court-Ordered Mediation Mean In Practice?
Where mediation takes place following a court direction or order, the process itself remains recognisably a mediation.
The mediator acts as an independent neutral and facilitates negotiations between the parties. They do not determine liability, assess damages by way of a binding judgment or replace the role of the parties' legal representatives.
Depending on the case, preparation may include:
- agreeing the mediator and practical arrangements;
- having a pre-mediation discussion with the mediator;
- identifying the principal issues preventing settlement;
- preparing concise position statements;
- providing an appropriately focused bundle;
- confirming that the relevant decision-makers will be available; and
- ensuring that the client understands the purpose and parameters of the mediation.
The mediation may then involve a combination of joint discussions and confidential private sessions.
The objective is to provide a structured opportunity to determine whether the dispute, or particular issues within it, can be resolved without requiring further litigation.
ADR, Conduct And Costs
The costs implications of ADR require careful treatment.-
Participating appropriately in an ADR process may demonstrate constructive engagement with the court's case management objectives.
Equally, failure to engage appropriately with ADR may have costs consequences.
The CPR permits the court, when exercising its discretion as to costs, to consider the parties' conduct in relation to ADR. This can include failure to comply with an ADR order and, in appropriate circumstances, an unreasonable failure to engage in ADR.
For legal teams, the practical point is that decisions concerning ADR should form part of considered case management rather than being treated as an administrative exercise.
The reasons for participating, proposing a particular process or taking a particular position in relation to ADR should be assessed in the context of the individual claim. Further, those reasons should be recorded: the record may be needed to support the position taken at case management hearing or when costs are considered.
Mediation As A Risk-Management Tool In PI Claims
Even where mediation arises because of judicial encouragement or direction, the process can provide a useful opportunity to reassess litigation risk.
Personal injury claims can involve significant areas of uncertainty, including:
- disputed liability;
- complex medical causation;
- competing expert evidence;
- prognosis;
- future care and accommodation;
- loss of earnings and pension claims;
- contributory negligence; and
- substantial differences in the parties' assessment of quantum.
A structured mediation allows legal teams to explore these issues outside the dynamics of conventional bilateral negotiation.
Private discussions with the mediator can help parties test assumptions, examine the consequences of proceeding to trial and understand more clearly what is preventing settlement.
This does not require either party to concede its case. The purpose is to assess litigation risk realistically and determine whether an acceptable resolution is available.
Managing Time And Litigation Costs
The timing of ADR can have significant commercial implications in personal injury litigation.
As a claim approaches trial, further expenditure may be required for expert evidence, conferences, witness preparation, counsel, trial bundles and attendance at the final hearing.
If a claim is capable of resolution, mediation before some or all of those costs are incurred may materially change the overall economics of the case.
Potential benefits include:
- Earlier Resolution: A successful mediation can conclude a claim pre-proceedings or before some of the later procedural stages and trial preparation are required.
- Cost Control: Earlier settlement may prevent further litigation expenditure from accumulating.
- Fee-Earner Capacity: For claimant firms, resolving suitable claims earlier can release experienced fee-earner capacity and assist WIP conversion.
- Defendant And Insurer Certainty: Earlier resolution can assist with legal spend, indemnity exposure, reserving and file closure.
- Narrowing The Issues: Even where a claim does not settle completely, a productive ADR process may identify or narrow areas of disagreement, potentially improving the efficiency of subsequent negotiations or litigation.
Mediation should therefore be assessed not simply by asking whether a case will settle on the day, but by considering whether the process can improve the management and potential resolution of the dispute.
When Should PI Practitioners Consider Mediation?
The possibility of a court order should not be the first point at which ADR is considered.
A more proactive approach is to review suitability at key stages of the claim.
Potential triggers include:
- you reach the point are ready to issue proceedings;
- sufficient medical and expert evidence becoming available;
- service of schedules and counter-schedules of loss;
- a significant difference emerging between the parties' valuations;
- direct negotiations or a JSM reaching an impasse;
- a substantial procedural or costs milestone (such as case management conference) is approaching;
- complex multi-party or contribution issues;
- sensitive circumstances requiring a carefully managed negotiation process;
- the claim involves a psychological or psychiatric element or
- the court raising ADR during case management.
The strategic question is whether mediation is likely to add value at that particular point in the claim.
Too early, and the parties may lack sufficient information to negotiate effectively. Too late, and substantial avoidable litigation costs may already have been incurred.
Supporting Legal Teams: Trust ADR And ADR Champions
Trust ADR works alongside claimant and defendant solicitors, counsel and other legal professionals to provide access to experienced independent neutrals for personal injury, clinical negligence and civil disputes.
Where mediation or neutral evaluation is being considered following a court direction, or where practitioners are assessing whether to propose ADR proactively, Trust ADR can assist with process planning, mediator or evaluator selection and practical preparation.
For firms seeking to develop a more systematic internal approach to ADR, Trust ADR also offers the ADR Champions programme.
The programme is designed to help firms build internal awareness and establish a clearer route for practitioners dealing with ADR issues.
Participating firms can benefit from:
- A Designated ADR Contact: A nominated practitioner within the firm who can act as an internal point of contact and liaise with Trust ADR.
- Practical Process Guidance: Support when considering mediation or neutral evaluation suitability, timing, neutral expertise and preparation.
- Knowledge Sharing: Relevant updates concerning ADR case law, procedural developments, the Civil Procedure Rules and evolving court practice.
- Training And Practical Support: Resources to help practitioners develop confidence in discussing ADR with clients and preparing effectively when mediation or neutral evaluation is proposed, encouraged or ordered.
The objective is to help legal teams treat ADR as part of effective case strategy rather than simply as a response to a court direction.
Responding To A Court Direction Or Considering ADR?
If the court has raised ADR in a personal injury or clinical negligence claim, or you are considering whether mediation or neutral evaluation should be proposed before the next significant procedural milestone, Trust ADR can discuss the available options.
We can consider the nature of the dispute, the issues preventing resolution, the timing of the process and the availability of an appropriately experienced mediator or evaluator before the parties decide how to proceed.
Contact Trust ADR to discuss mediator or evaluator availability for an active personal injury or clinical negligence claim.
Image Source: Envato



.webp)